Showing posts with label indian. Show all posts
Showing posts with label indian. Show all posts

22 February 2007

chief illiniwek

since no one ever reads this i feel fairly free to give my opinion on the whole chief illiniwek situation.

the thing that i find bad about the pro-chief arguments is that it is always framed in a completely western context. consider the following:
  • the chief has never been "portrayed" by a native american student
  • everyone here still calls native americans "indians" or "american indians," those words are completely based on some european thinking that he's on the wrong continent... sensible canadians call them "first nations" while we're still playing cowboys and indians
  • how many "symbols," a favoured way of chief backers of getting away from "mascot," dance around at sporting events at half-time
  • the chief logo is actually trademarked... how can you say that you're honouring native americans by actually trademarking the symbol so that they can't use it... honoring something usually means putting it in the public domain so that all can take part... intellectual property is a fairly western idea placed on a subjugated culture
  • a common pro-chief argument is that no one from the illini tribe (which is actually pronounced "ih-LIE-nee") has complained... there is no more people from the illini tribe since they have been decimated by war in the 1700s and have been integrated into the peoria tribe of oklahoma at their reservation
  • the dance performed has no native american significance... it was completely made up
  • how many native americans do you think danced to marching band music?
i've spent too much on this already. i'm just disappointed that there so little respect for the views of minorities... especially when the minority was treated so badly in the past... how quickly do we forget how we have treated others... trail of tears... japanese internment... abu garib... remembering and honouring is one thing... performing a caricature at sports events is another...